Copyright © 2007-2017 Russ Dewey
When everything is going right for an athlete, the athlete may report an altered sense of time and a feeling of effortless, highly competent performance. Self-consciousness is diminished, as the individual becomes totally absorbed by game. Such a state is sometimes called "playing unconscious."
What factors can lead to "playing unconscious"? What is the "flow state"?
Michael Csikszentmihalyi (CHICK-zent-
A person feels totally in control during a flow state without thinking about it. Self-consciousness recedes into the background as the total focus is upon present activity.
Bob Beamon reported such a heightened state of concentration during his world record long jump of 29' 2 1/2" at the 1968 summer Olympics in Mexico City. It was more than 2 feet farther than the previous world record, and Beamon's record stood for over 20 years until Mike Powell broke it in 1991.
Looking back and trying to explain his 1968 jump, Beamon described it this way:
There is no answer for the performance. But everything was just perfect for it, the runway, my takeoff–I went six feet in the air when usually I'd go about five–and my concentration was perfect. It never happened quite that way before. I blocked out everything in the world, except my focus on the jump. (Berkow, 1984)
Of course, that is a retrospective self-report, the weakest form of psychological data. But it is consistent with descriptions by many other athletes.
What are common elements in descriptions of great moments in sport
Ravizza (1977) was one of the first sport psychologists to describe how athletes felt during their greatest moments. Interviews of 20 male and female athletes who played in 12 different sports yielded the following characteristics:
Loss of fear–no fear of failure
No thinking of performance
Total immersion in the activity
Narrow focus of attention
Effortless performance–not forcing it
Feeling of being in complete control
Time-space disorientation (usually slowed down)
Perceive universe to be integrated and unified
Unique, temporary, involuntary experience
Garfield and Bennett (1984) identified eight mental and physical conditions that athletes described as being characteristic of the feelings they have at those moments when they are doing something extraordinarily well:
1. Mentally relaxed. This was described as a sense of inner calm. Some athletes also reported a sense of time being slowed down and having a high degree of concentration. By contrast, loss of concentration was associated with a sense of everything happening too fast and being out of control.
2. Physically relaxed. Feeling of muscles being loose with movements fluid and sure.
3. Confident/optimistic. A positive attitude, feelings of self-confidence and optimism. Being able to keep poise and feelings of strength and control even during potentially threatening challenges.
4. Focused on the present. Athletes reported body and mind working as one unit, with no thoughts of the past or future. The body performed automatically, without conscious or deliberate mental effort.
5. Highly energized. A high-energy state frequently described as feelings of joy, ecstasy, intensity, and being "charged" or "hot."
6. Extraordinary awareness. This was a state of mind in which the athletes were acutely aware of their own bodies and surrounding athletes. They reported an uncanny ability to know what the other athletes are going to do, and they responded accordingly.
7. In control. The body and mind seem to do automatically exactly what is right, yet there is no sense of exerting or imposing control.
8. In the cocoon. The feeling of being in an envelope, being completely detached from the external environment and any potential distortions. Also a sense of complete access to all of one's powers and skills. Athletes "in the cocoon" are able to avoid loss of concentration and accelerated, tight-muscled, out-of-control feelings.
If you want to be a contrarian, not simply endorsing all positive statements about flow states, you could locate some contradictions in the idealized descriptions. People are "unconscious" but "extraordinarily aware."
They are relaxed but also energized. But maybe that is just the point; the so-called flow state is when those opposites come together, because a highly practiced and highly motivated skill, which would require great effort or impossible strength in a person without preparation, is allowed to...flow without impediment.
Jackson (1996) used "in-depth interviews with 14 male and 14 female elite athletes" to compare their perceptions of optimal states to Csikszentmihalyi's description. 22 of the 28 athletes confirmed three features of the flow state.
The athletes were familiar with the the paradox of control (feeling in control without having to think about it). They experienced being so involved that the activity seemed spontaneous and automatic. They also noticed times of exceptional concentration (being completely focused).
Which elements of the flow state did athletes confirm? Which elements were less commonly described?
However, "other dimensions were not so universally endorsed." Athletes spoke of effort, not the effortlessness Csikszentmihalyi describes. (Perhaps the athletes interviewed by Jackson interpreted effort as referring to directed energy, while Csikszentmihalyi was referring to difficulty and struggling.)
The most universally experienced element was automaticity of a flow state: "playing unconscious." In other words, a skilled action is performed without detailed, step-by-step, conscious control.
What is the most universally experienced element?
That actually meshes with Mandler's idea that consciousness is called upon for troubleshooting. When an athletic performance is going very well, activity can be allowed to unfold without that type of correction.
Also relevant is the discussion in Chapter 7 (Cognition) where the argument was made that overlearning of skills produces automaticity, and this is necessary for creativity, because in the midst of creative acts, there is no time to stop and put things together piecemeal. Nideffer (1992) writes:
Playing in the zone first requires a level of physical skill that enables you to perform without having to think about it. For example, when playing in the zone, the tennis player doesn't talk to herself about how to play the point, how to set up for a shot, or how to hit the ball.
When developing and learning new skills, you talk to yourself a great deal. You remind yourself of simple things: "Take your time, step up to the foul line, and take a deep breath. Bend your knees, and follow through."
This self-talk helps you develop and grow, enabling you to make needed adjustments and corrections during the learning process. It reminds you to practice the same thing until it becomes automatic. This self-talk is greatly diminished when you are playing in a game.
How does the level of self-talk change, from the time one is first learning skills to the time one plays in a game?
At this point, you are attempting to use skills that are already developed. When you are in the zone, you don't have to think tactics because the appropriate move is obvious to you. Things like setting up and preparing early should happen automatically. (Nideffer, 1992)
Berkow, I. (1984, March 13) '68 jump astounds Beamon today. New York Times, p.Y26.
Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1990) Flow: The psychology of optimal experience. New York: Harper & Row.
Garfield, C. A. & Bennett, H. Z. (1984) Peak performance: Mental training techniques of the world's greatest athletes. New York: Warner Bros.
Jackson, S. A. (1996). Toward a conceptual understanding to the flow experience in elite athletes. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 67, 76-90.
Nideffer, R. M. (1992). Psyched to Win. Champaign, IL: Leisure Press
Ravizza, K. (1977). A subjective study of the athlete's greatest moment in sport. In Proceedings of the Canadian Psychomotor Symposium, Psychomotor Learning and Sport Psychology Symposium (pp. 399-404). Toronto, Canada: Coaching Association of Canada.
Write to Dr. Dewey at email@example.com.
Copyright © 2007-2017 Russ Dewey